Follow
What drives me is the unknown..

The Mystery of the Damascus Sword and India’s Materials Heritage

In this blog, I would like to tell you the story of carbon steel and the India connection. Carbon steel is the most used engineering material today and accounts for 85-90% of steel produced worldwide.

To tell this story one must start at Salaudin and Richard the Great facing-off during the crusades.  It is said that Richard the Great cut through a tree trunk with one swipe of his sword to show his might and the capability of his sword.  In response, Salaudin is purported to have just tossed a silk scarf into the air and let it slide off his blade’s edge, cleanly cutting it into two.  Richard recognized that it was indeed a great sword that could cleave free falling soft material without the use of any force.  Salaudin’s sword was known to be a Damascine sword.

There is now a general agreement that the Damascus steel which made its way into the western world through the crusades was produced in India rather than in Damascus.  This steel was known as Wootz steel, potentially derived from the word ‘ukku’ which means steel in Telugu and Kannada.  Damascus swords were known to be extremely hard and flexible to the hilt and able to cleave a free-falling silk scarf or a block of wood with the same ease.

A good person to talk to on this subject is Sharada Srinivasan.  I first met her when her father, Dr. Srinivasan, retired director of the Bhabha Atomic Research Center, gave a talk at my invitation to the GE Global Research team at Bangalore.  I was surprised to know that a field such as archaeometallurgy existed outside of Indiana Jones movies.  Sharada has a Ph.D. in this area, and has worked on topics such as the pancha-loha(five metal alloys – traditionally described as alloys of gold, silver, copper, brass, and iron used in South Indian metal sculptures), and Wootz steel.  In her paper on the topic, she concludes that high-grade ultra-high carbon steel was indeed produced by crucible processes in South India.

Verhoeven et al. have researched the topic of Wootz steel indepth including the question as to why the art was lost.  Verhoeven et al. conclude that in order to produce Wootz quality steel, a smith had to fulfill three conditions:

  1. The ore which Wootz is made from needed to have trace elements of impurities such as vanadium which was crucial for the textured pattern of the Wootz steels
  2. High phosphor levels characterize the Wootz steel blades.  This indicates that the material would not have enough tensile strength to resist stresses from cooling of traditional forging processes of the west.   Hence, the forging techniques must have been different than those used for other types of steel known in the western world.  Heat treatment techniques would require decarburizing the surface and producing a low-carbon ductile surface rim that protected the interior regions during the cooling process.
  3. The surface decarburized regions are ground off to produce the characteristic surface patterns of Wootz steel.  The grinding process itself might not have been simple.
  4. It is speculated that Wootz was made in India from 500 B.C. to about 1600 A.D.  Verhoeven et al. also speculate that the art of making steel was probably a trade secret passed on to select apprentices by master smiths.  The master smith would have taught the apprentice the heat treatment process and the grinding process described above.  Potentially, the ore being used naturally had the trace impurities required in the process of making Wootz.  Once the source of the ore was exhausted, the techniques did not work as the smiths never figured out the science of composition of the ores which made their craft possible.  So Verhoeven et al. state,

“…with time, the smiths who knew about the technique died out without passing it on to their apprentices (since it no longer worked), so even if a similar source was later found, the knowledge was no longer around to exploit it.”

In addition to carbon steel, there are several examples of India’s leadership in material technologies including cast steel used for Tippu’s rockets and nano-silver used to cover Indian food items.

Roddam Narasimha is a walking encyclopedia on India and Indian technology.   The Caltech Aerospace Ph.D., career academician with the Indian Institute of Science, who is the past director of leading Indian research organizations such National Aeronautical Laboratories and National Institute for Advanced Sciences, has a balanced approach to looking into the past Indian technical accomplishments.  As he says , “Indian scholars have tended to take extreme positions of either saying all that is of technical value came from the West or, at the other end, that all that is accepted as science today came from India.”  He himself has spent good amount of research effort on answering what he calls ‘Needham’s question’:

With the appearance on the scene of intensive studies of mathematics, science, technology and medicine in great non-European civilization, debate is likely to sharpen, for the failure of China and India to give rise to distinctively modern science while being ahead of Europe for fourteen previous centuries.

Roddam has studied in great detail what could be the single indigenous development in India during the early days of the Industrial Revolution in Britain – Rockets.  Tippu Sultan and his father Hyder Ali – rulers of the Mysore state for a period in the 18th century – were known for their ability to lead armies to victory.  A key element in their victorious escapades was the use of rockets.  There were three elements of innovation to their use of rockets.  First was the use of high quality Indian steel, which allowed one to pack in a lot more gunpowder than would be possible with lower quality steels (more a testimonial to Indian Iron ore than to the processing); second was the use of swords as stabilizers which as the rocket flared into sky and descended on the enemy tended to come down sword first causing severe injuries; and third was the use of several rockets in unison with launch angles computed to cover the enemy ranks with massive concentrated rocket attack.  This rocket attack caused the enemy ranks to wither away in the face of a humiliating defeat.  Roddam describes an incident from the fourth Anglo-Mysore war of 1799, where Col. Wellesley (later the Lord Wellington) and his troops were badly beaten back at Sultanpet.  Roddam quotes a young English officer’s journal thus:

The rockets and musketry from 20,000 of the enemy were incessant.  No hail could be thicker.  Every illumination of blue light was accompanied by a shower of rockets, some of which entered the head of the column, passing through the rear, causing death, wounds, and dreadful lacerations from the long bamboos of twenty or thirty feet, which are invariably attached to them.

It is also known that William Congreve exported the Indian rocket technology and further developed it into what are now known as Congreve Rockets, which were successfully used in later wars by the British.  Roddam also concludes that the success of Congreve’s improvements was due to the understanding and application of Newton’s laws of motion and systematic approach to research.

Currently nano silver is being used in microcidal applications from washing machines to wound healing.  For the longest time silver beaten into thin sheets has been used on our sweet meats and on pan (betel leaf with various admixture inside).  I picked-up a few sheets of these silver foils to verify their nanostructure and the results from transmission electron microscope analysis verify the purity of silver (very few precipitates high in carbon) and the existence of a nano microstructure with severe deformation.  Current research points to the anti-viral, anti-inflammatory, re-epitheliazation, and anti-hemorrhagic properties of silver in its nano form.  It is really interesting that the way silver gets its nano structure in this case is by taking normal metallic silver and pounding it (traditionally between animal intestine layers) to its nano form!  This age-old knowledge from India is luckily not a lost art, and is being rediscovered by the scientists of the new millennium.

Applying new sciences or new materials for the health and comfort of humankind is the story of engineering progress.  Harnessing materials directly by humans predates the emergence of science, as we know it today.  One of the markers of progress of a society has been its ability to work metals and its alloys.  Today, we have come a long way in materials advances.  Recently a friend’s son had an accident and ended up with a decent size cut on his head.  Not too long ago, this wound would have been treated with 4-5 sutures.  Not anymore.  Doctors used a liquid adhesive to close the wound!  The liquid adhesive forms a microbial shield while the wound heals without the use of a needle.  Materials research does take a long time, but research from the last several decades is now bearing fruit and becoming useful applications:

  • Composites have been used for several centuries in many different forms.  A composite material is an engineered structure made up of two or more materials with different material properties and the differences in properties produce a synergistically stronger and lighter structure for the purposes of structural use.  Recent advances in composite technology have made it possible to mold large structural parts with high strengths and resistance to impact.  Also, Ceramic Matrix Composites are increasingly being deployed to take advantage of the high-temperature properties of ceramics and at the same time overcome the brittleness of monolithic ceramics.  Furthermore, the interest in green products has driven the use of natural fiber in composites.  In the distant horizon, the possibility exists to build automotive, rail, and airframe structures using high strength composites that are biodegradable under certain specially designed trigger conditions.
  • Superconductor research has not yet hit the critical point due to the fact that the temperature at which superconductivity is achieved is not practical for most applications.  However, with the theories behind superconductivity and the various compounds with superconductivity being intensively researched, the probability of hitting a critical point in superconductivity exists which would throw open several electro-mechanical and medical applications.
  • Rare earth magnets have been around for past few decades, however the cost points were not at a place to meet large scale needs.  Rare earth magnets are 10-20 times stronger than other permanent magnets.  With most of the technology around rare-earth magnets coming out of patents in the 2003, the costs have dropped setting into motion wider use of rare-earth magnets in several applications replacing wound copper coil magnet configurations.  Additionally, with the confluence of nanotechnology and rare-earth materials, the possibility now exists to dramatically improve the power and efficiency of electric machines and other power systems including the possibility of wireless power transfer, and efficient automotives.
  • Another area of materials’ research that will create a huge impact is that of meta-materials – man made materials that exhibit properties based on structure rather than composition.  As an example, it is feasible to build negative refractive index meta-materials (something not observed in nature) – this will enable much better optical instrumentation for entertainment, medicine, and microscopy, and eventually extend its reach to higher efficiency machines and power-systems.

As we move forward, India has every opportunity to develop leadership in materials and use this to solve tough problems in healthcare, energy and transportation for India and the world.  A particular focus, in my opinion, should be composite materials.  Driven by the use of composites in the Indian aerospace industry (rockets, satellites, missiles, light combat aircraft, advanced light helicopter), we have fairly mature capabilities in the area of composite structures.  Technical assistance and soft loans from the Technology Information Forecasting and Assessment Council (TIFAC), a unit of the Department of Science and Technology as well other government initiatives are in the right direction to enhance India’s capabilities.  Joint ventures and global collaborations are now required to ensure India works at the leading edge of the technology and gets better at raw material development while further strengthening the applications end of capabilities. It will be great to aim for a century of Indian materials.  Remember the Damascus Sword!

 

Post Your Comment
Name
Required
Email
Required, will not be published
Comment
All comments are moderated
 

Comment
Great topic; even I am of opinion that much of the scientific practices that exists, have been used in India, China & Middle east. For example, I remember one incident from my house. In orissa, lot of Aluminium utensils are used in Kitchen, but whenever pickles are made & stored, they are never used. Finally in my school studies, I found out the reason of reaction taking place between pickle & Al to form poisonous product. But it was amazing how my mother & grand mother, who are illiterate knew about wrong happening between Al & pickles.
Excellent topic Gopi, i had never heard of this...Regards
Fascinating. This is a great article with so much of details. Thanks for publishing it.
Mr Katragadda, would you care to shed some light on the rust-resistant properties of the famous iron pillar of Delhi? Were its makers from a different school of iron-making?
Gopichand Katragadda
There are individuals who have done good amount of research on this topic, and I will draw their attention to this question. The time period ascribed to the Pillar's manufacture is the 4th century AD very much in the period of metalworking excellence in India that I discuss through the much later story of the Damascus sword. The iron pillar however involves much more technology such as forge welding and heat treatment of large scale wrought iron. The corrosion resistance is attributed to several possibilities including dry weather (of Delhi), metal composition, heat treatment, protective oxide layer, etc...
Thanks to Mr.Katragadda for sharing your views and imp details which are almost a history now As i am still part of steel making process such notes /reviews keep me on my toes. May be we were in hurry to grow ..grow faster borrowing anything everything ..without having a glance at our assets, development and its processing. But these are still fundamental of public sector. I would like to recall Dr.K L Bhat of REC Surthkal and Dr.K Aprameyan of Ex BEML were always calling for younger breed of metallurgy to pay more attention. Wish we make good use of it now and great future for next gen. Regards, Pushpa
Gopichand Katragadda
Thanks Pushpa... Yes, metals (alloys) that operate close their melting point and last 20+ years are at the core of energy and aviation development...
 
 
(Gopi Katragadda is the Managing Director at GE India Technology Center)

Be it going down unknown roads of a new city, or peeling the onion of a known fact to discover fascinating unknown layers, what drives me is the unknown… The amount I have learnt trying to decipher the Indus script is as valuable as the eventual goal of decipherment. As a boy, one summer, I learnt to make soap from my English teacher, and I sold the soap to neighbors and friends.
I made soap because I enjoyed the act of creating and I sold soap because it was a validation that what I created had value… Today, deep down, I am still that boy who makes and sells soap…
Leading GE Technology in India provides me the ultimate platform to probe unknown corners of Energy, Healthcare, Transportation, and Aviation. We create intellectual property and put it into products that solve some of the world’s toughest problems. Over the last decade, the work done by inventors at GE India has resulted in over 1500 patents being filed by the Parent General Electric Company.
My book on innovation titled ‘Smash Innovation,’ explores the barriers to innovation in India and how we could break those barriers. This blog is again my exploration of how to make this a century of Indian Innovation.
 
 
 
Most Popular
Gopi Katragadda's Activity Feed
October 22, 2012 12:05 pm by Omprakash Mall
Great topic; even I am of opinion that much of the scientific practices that exists, have been used in India, China & Middle east. For example, I remember one incident from my house. In orissa, lot of Aluminium utensils are used in Kitchen, but whenever pickles are made & stored, they are never used...
October 18, 2012 15:42 pm by Gopichand Katragadda
There are individuals who have done good amount of research on this topic, and I will draw their attention to this question. The time period ascribed to the Pillar's manufacture is the 4th century AD very much in the period of metalworking excellence in India that I discuss through the much later...
October 18, 2012 13:55 pm by Nikhil
Excellent topic Gopi, i had never heard of this...Regards
October 17, 2012 16:13 pm by Rahul
Fascinating. This is a great article with so much of details. Thanks for publishing it.
Peter Griffin
Peter Griffin
October 15, 2012 21:04 pm by Peter Griffin
Mr Katragadda, would you care to shed some light on the rust-resistant properties of the famous iron pillar of Delhi? Were its makers from a different school of iron-making?