Follow
Shravan Bhat
I live sporting weekend to sporting weekend

Anderson vs Steyn: Who is the Best Fast Bowler?

Photo credit: David Gray / Reuters

James Anderson is jubliant. Photo credit: David Gray / Reuters

On Sunday, England’s Jimmy Anderson became the fourth English bowler to take 300 test wickets when he helped skittle out New Zealand.

Anderson’s bowling coach, David Saker, made a big statement: he called Anderson the most skilful bowler around. Note: not the best, but the most skilful. He meant that Anderson’s control of outswing, inswing and reverse swing across conditions is second to none.

Many would dispute that. The many who believe that Dale Steyn is the one way ahead of the pack.

One thing is undisputed though: these two pacers are head and shoulders above the rest. Here’s why:
• Their ability to get wickets across all conditions. Anderson and Steyn have both succeeded in India, no paradise for fast bowlers.
• They have the cleanest bowling actions I’ve seen in a long time. Dale Steyn is a rhythm bowler and once he’s found his groove, he doesn’t look to be exerting himself at all. Look at how his opening partner Morne Morkel strains himself to get pace and bounce. James Anderson cocks the ball by his cheek just as you’re taught in school; none of Andrew Flintoff’s flailing arms.
• They’ve managed to steer clear of injuries. One needs only look at India and Australia in recent times for cases where injuries to strike bowlers have killed the team’s chances.

It’s an intriguing exercise to look at their stats side by side.

They’re around the same age (Anderson is 30 and Steyn 29), and made their test débuts within a year of each other (Anderson, 2003, Steyn 2004). Steyn took just 61 tests to reach the 300 wicket mark, whereas Anderson took 81.

 

Tests Steyn Anderson
Wickets 332 305
% Away 42% 38%
Average 22.65 30.14
Balls Bowled 13666 17858
Overs / Wicket 7 10

 

Anderson’s ability to swing the ball both ways is extremely useful and the fact that he developed it recently is commendable. His 5-52 at Galle in 2012 showed his range of skills: the first two wicket-taking balls moved away from left-handers, the third reversed into a right hander’s pads, the fourth was an off-cutter that bowled a right-hander and the fifth left the right hander. Anderson’s seam position is perhaps the best in the world and he is able to generate ferocious outswing to left-handers. In my opinion, fast bowlers like Anderson and Steyn are strike bowlers—especially in test matches—and my main interest is them getting top order wickets. Even though Anderson has bowled 700 more test overs, Steyn still has more wickets and a far better average. In fact, at 22.65, his test average is inferior only to McGrath, Ambrose, Marshall and Hadlee in the all-time highest wicket takers list.

YouTube Preview Image

Dale Steyn’s 7-51 at Nagpur was a master class in fast bowling in hot, dry conditions. He caused the Indian batsmen all sorts of trouble by bowling good length balls at searing pace. While Anderson is all about a controlled seam, Steyn’s main asset is much more primal: sheer speed. He is quick enough to blast through batting attacks on the subcontinent. Anderson is a thinking bowler, but when you can bowl 140kph reverse swingers, perhaps you don’t need to think too much. Steyn also has a higher percentage of wickets taken away from home. There’s no question he’s the better test bowler.

YouTube Preview Image

The two are much more evenly matched when it comes to ODI cricket. Interestingly though, Anderson has bowled more than twice as many balls as Steyn has.

 

ODIs Steyn Anderson
Wickets 100 229
% Away 49% 54%
Average 29.33 30.06
Balls Bowled 3579 8273
Overs / Wicket 6 6

 

Anderson has a marginally higher percentage of wickets taken away from home in ODIs. Though they are neck-and-neck in the 50-over game, Steyn is ahead in the shortest format. Because of the IPL, Steyn has played a lot more T20 cricket than Anderson and it shows.

 

T20 Steyn Anderson
Wickets 176 55
Average 19.1 31.41
Overs / Wicket 3 4

 

It is clear that Dale Steyn is the better T20 bowler. His average in T20 Internationals is a staggering 16.64.

Photo credit: Rogan Ward / Reuters

Dale Steyn shows off his five-wicket haul. Photo credit: Rogan Ward / Reuters

I can see where David Saker is coming from when he said James Anderson is the most skilful bowler in the world. He has worked hard to strengthen his wrists and release. And Anderson has more variation and seam control than Steyn. But is bowling quick not a skill too? Steyn is a good five miles an hour faster than Anderson and tends to swing it later. Anderson, however, is improving very fast: his test average has come down about 2 runs per year since 2007.

Overall, I would have to say that Steyn is the better bowler but Anderson is on an upward trajectory. What constitutes skill? I’ll leave to you to decide.

 

Post Your Comment
Name
Required
Email
Required, will not be published
Comment
All comments are moderated
 

Comment
Dale Steyn is one of the greatest fast bowlers of all time, James Anderson is not, end of story.
I think Dale Steyn is the best bowler in the current table. His speciality is that he can maintain his line and length in any part of the world in any conditions and he has proved that he is capable. But Anderson working on the same and not matured enough in indian conditions. He has struggled in the last indian tour but at the same time he emerged as a good bowler in the previous home series against Indians.
Always steyn is best in is bowling and i say steyn best
Reading this at Starbucks Horniman Circle. Makes special reading over a Mocha... Technically Refreshing ie substantive and as usual lovely phrases and expressions.. SHRAVAN do I sound like a teacher overseeing some homework... Kya Karein patronizing and proud Uncle !
 
 
Shravan Bhat
Loud, proud Arsenal fan: I went to a Premier League football match every month for the three years I spent at university in England. I had the privilege of going for three of the last four cricket World Cups. Along side football and cricket, I watch tennis, F1 and golf regularly. I want to tell you why sports are great and why they can bring about positive change.

I've lived in Singapore, London, Hong Kong, Bangalore, Birmingham, Frankfurt (Oder) and now Mumbai. After studying Business & International Relations at Aston University, I joined Forbes India Magazine. My major interests are foreign language movies, food and international affairs. I love old European cities, sushi and the Lord of the Rings.
 
 
 
Most Popular
Shravan Bhat's Activity Feed
November 30, 2013 15:05 pm by Steve
Dale Steyn is one of the greatest fast bowlers of all time, James Anderson is not, end of story.
October 11, 2013 11:52 am by Saravanan V K
I think Dale Steyn is the best bowler in the current table. His speciality is that he can maintain his line and length in any part of the world in any conditions and he has proved that he is capable. But Anderson working on the same and not matured enough in indian conditions. He has struggled in t...
August 04, 2013 14:58 pm by Sj sakthi
Always steyn is best in is bowling and i say steyn best
May 24, 2013 11:24 am by Sandip Das
Reading this at Starbucks Horniman Circle. Makes special reading over a Mocha... Technically Refreshing ie substantive and as usual lovely phrases and expressions.. SHRAVAN do I sound like a teacher overseeing some homework... Kya Karein patronizing and proud Uncle !