Follow
Meeta Sengupta
An experienced educationist and advisor to CxOs, school leaders and foundations

How much do we know about Education in India

Everyone has an opinion on education. Start a conversation at a dinner table, a tea shop, an academic seminar, a global conference, a train, a bus or flight – everyone you meet will have something to say about it. Often, they will know precisely how bad it is, how much worse it has become and what needs to be done to fix the ills. When I say precisely, I don’t mean that – I mean with a great deal of authority. Very definite and well articulated opinions. And they may well be right. Because nobody can really answer (most of) the big questions in education in India with any degree of precision.

Policy:
The holy grail here is evidence based policy making. It would obviously be great if every decision made had a solid basis in proven hypothesis. If we knew for sure, to take a facetious example, that children study better in white shirts than blue shirts, and this had been tested rigorously, then it would be easy to create a policy that tends towards white shirts as school uniforms. This is also better for policy makers as they have the evidence to fall back upon and even justify their decisions. In practice of course evidence is just one part of the policy making puzzle and may even prove to be inconvenient in some circumstances. Yet, it is what stands closest to fact in the vast unknown.

Data:
The first hurdle of course is the availability of data. There is some available on the ministry website and some with affiliated institutions. Some data is gathered in large studies such as those conducted by the Azim Premji foundation, Pratham, Accountability Initiative etc. and these answer specific questions each year. The Karnataka Learning Partnership and Centre for Civil Society are taking the lead on compiling some data that are available to all while investors and private consulting firms have their own data sets that are not available in the public domain. Each of these serves a limited purpose and researchers often find themselves stuck because they have no credible information sources or good data unless they set up a data collection process themselves as part of their studies. That is either very expensive and time consuming or forces them to dramatically reduce the scope of their work.

Research:
There is a wide range of research done on education in India, only some of it academic. (On a personal note, I wonder if I should still be surprised when one silo has not even heard of the work done in another – oh right, I did say silo) Firstly there is academic work that is being done across schools of education in India and abroad (primarily in the UK and the USA). The quality and impact of the work differs greatly depending upon the access and funding they receive. There is some excellent work of limited scope and reach being published in small journals and post- conference books that gets lost in the sheer volumes of papers being produced in an uncurated world. Then there are rigorous investigations by celebrity scholars – my favourites being Prof. Geeta Kingdom of the Institute of Education and Prof. Karthik Muralidharan of UC San Diego who have told cogent and critical truths about teaching and learning in India. Much research is also done in the investor community – some of it philanthropic, some driven by pure investment principles. Central Square Foundation, for example, incubates many projects that do much good in the education sector and curates information and data that forms the basis of investment (and re-investment) research. Consulting firms with education arms too co-create interesting and useful research in the field of education.

Application of Research:
Useful research? Did I hear laughter in the background? For research to be useful, it not only needs to be rigorous and relevant (and much of it clearly is) but also needs to be accessible. Over and above that – it needs to address real questions that help decision makers at all three levels – policy, institution and the classroom. If education is about benefiting the child (the marginal child as economists would say), then we need to be able to answer the questions schools and teachers ask regularly. In the past forty-eight hours, this is the range of questions I have been asked -

From a school owner – Is there a guide or research that points me to the characteristics teacher quality? In teacher selection – how do I recruit a good teacher? (We all know good teachers, we know their qualifications etc. which is partial knowledge)

From a School trust – What is the right proportion of male and female teachers that will enhance achievements of boys and girls? (K. Muralidharan had a paper that partially answered that question) (Of course, all recruitment has to be regardless of gender – so the question can only be about the impact of gender skew in the teacher cohort)

From a teacher-leader: Is a multi ability class better than streaming into ability sections? If I have been told that I must achieve high performance, and if achievement is my only goal , what are the consequences of my decision?

From the management of a large school group seeking to expand: Is it better to raise the grade level (from primary to secondary) or open another primary school if I want to serve my area better?

From a potential investor: What are the returns to investment to RTE compliance? -If I invest, is there a case for giving loans to ensure RTE (Right to Education act) compliance? Will I get my money back with a fair return?

From the management team of a small Business School: How do I fill seats in my B-School during this slowdown? Numbers in engineering and business schools are seen to be falling – is there a forecast that will help me plan capacity?

The answers are out there. Some have been researched, some await their turn. Most decisions will also depend upon the context, experience and ability of the person in charge. But it is better to have some validation based on good data. There is very little data, and much of it is not very good quality data. And so, we wait, unable to fully answer these questions and decide the our future education path.

Post Your Comment
Name
Required
Email
Required, will not be published
Comment
All comments are moderated
 

Comment
ANUPA KAUSHIK
A bad teacher (an Omnipresent creature) - Who does not allow the learning to happen in the name of education - & A Good Teacher (Species you do not really see now a days) - you barely find one As a science populariser, i started a campaign for science teachers (XI & XII) to let them know about studio physics that too free. The response is so slow and the school principals are oblivious. That is the state of our social strata, that is the state of our teachers, that is the state of science here in India, No wonder we do not have virtually any IP, could not earn good numbers in Nobel and are never known for NDIAN TECHNOLOGY
According to 2009 act, schooling is free to all children from the age of 6 to 14. but i don't see any huge growth in education system in India. Let see what will happen in coming years.
Ravikant Gupta
Wonderful post! Thanks for sharing such an extensively researched article.
Wonder full post very nicely researched that you very much for sharing.
The Indian government has radically failed in the core sectors like Health and Education. The big gap in quality of education in government and private hospital is well known. Government schools are available but the educated and rich people don't send their kids to these schools. In the UK, government schools are equally good and are either free or quite cheap. In India if some one wants good education or health services he has to go to a top school or hospital which are exorbitantly costly. That's where the problem is.
 
 
Meeta Sengupta
Meeta Sengupta works at the cusp of policy and practice across the education and skills spectrum and enjoys sharing her gleanings via her writing for a wider audience. She has been an investment banker, a researcher, an editor, a teacher and school leader across continents. A keen observer of how economics, foreign policy and investments affect the policy and thence practice of education, she works with leaders to design interventions that improve the quality and process of education. Designing education processes to realise the potential of individual students is at the centre of her education philosophy.

Meeta has worked both as a policy observer, and at the coalface of education across the board and across countries. She has served as a governor of an aided school, part of the management committee of a residential school, managed an academic centre in an elite post graduate management school and led a business school supported by a community college. She has worked with children, teenagers, business school and PhD candidates and has also worked with those seeking to rebuild their lives via education.

Meeta W Sengupta is a Fellow of the Salzburg Global Seminar, among others and can be contacted via her personal blog at meetawsengupta.wordpress.com/about
 
 
 
Meeta Sengupta'S POPULAR POST(S)
Most Popular
Meeta Sengupta's Activity Feed
June 04, 2014 10:05 am by ANUPA KAUSHIK
A bad teacher (an Omnipresent creature) - Who does not allow the learning to happen in the name of education - & A Good Teacher (Species you do not really see now a days) - you barely find one As a science populariser, i started a campaign for science teachers (XI & XII) to let them know about ...
May 24, 2014 11:32 am by Ajinder Kaur
According to 2009 act, schooling is free to all children from the age of 6 to 14. but i don't see any huge growth in education system in India. Let see what will happen in coming years.
March 04, 2014 11:28 am by Ravikant Gupta
Wonderful post! Thanks for sharing such an extensively researched article.
January 17, 2014 13:05 pm by Sidhee Singh
Wonder full post very nicely researched that you very much for sharing.
November 28, 2013 21:16 pm by Sanjay Abraham
The Indian government has radically failed in the core sectors like Health and Education. The big gap in quality of education in government and private hospital is well known. Government schools are available but the educated and rich people don't send their kids to these schools. In the UK, governm...