Taking Stock Of the Market
Image: Alok Brahmbhatt
n the best of times, Shankar Sharma is the kind of man who can piss the eternal optimist off with his grim, almost Taleb-esque predictions. Over the last one year, the Nifty has moved up 15 percent while stocks of medium-sized companies rose three times as much. These are the kind of returns that have left investors in every other part of the world beady-eyed and glazed over with envy. Add to this the facts coming from the manufacturing economy: Automobile sales are robust and truck operators are back in the market looking to expand their fleets. These are indications of an economy on the trot.
But the chief strategist at broking firm First Global sounds resolute in his forecast: The markets will fall 20 percent. That’s 3,500 points waiting to be lopped off the BSE Sensex. “The correction will happen when you least expect it to happen,” he says. “We need to understand the world economy is not in the best of health and expecting Indian equities to do well is misplaced hope,” he adds with gravitas.
The problem with Sharma is he’s the kind of grim Oracle you can’t wish away. He’s the man who called the debacle that was 2008 much earlier than anybody else did.
Now, Ridham Desai works two kilometres away from where Sharma operates out of. The head of equities business at Morgan Stanley looks every part a man who believes the market will gain 10 percent over the next couple of months. He says Indian stocks are valued just about right — in fact, there’s some steam left in prices — and that the Sensex will breach 19,000 by the end of the year.
Why? Because, while the recovery so far from the economic slowdown has been led by consumption surge, growth is now coming on the back of investments that add capacities. Not just that, capacity utilisation in India’s manufacturing and services companies is going up sharply. There are gains to be had from that as well. He doesn’t care much for the fires burning in Europe and other parts of the world. The problem is, like Sharma, Desai cannot be ignored at all. Last year, he argued the Sensex would move from 14,000 to 19,000. It almost, almost got there.
But the bigger problem is for regular investing folks. Do you align with the Sharma camp and simply focus on protecting your backside? Or do you go with Desai’s world view and hitch your wagon to the stars?
Let us face it. It is not easy taking a call on the markets today. This is one of those extraordinary times when even the professional investors go numb with paralysis. In the web of complex variables that dictate the day-to-day movement of the stock market, there is no one who can see beyond current volatility.
The markets have surprised all classes of investors too often in the last couple of years. Fund managers repeatedly failed to outperform broad-market indices and old correlation theories between risky assets and safe havens turned to dust. Investors who sold off and went into cash hopelessly watched as the market suddenly turned course and gave 50 percent returns in less than a year. Most people who made money did so serendipitously. But the sort of punishment that the actively bullish and bearish investors got for their decisions has made most of them wary of taking a decision again.
But given that inertia isn’t a legitimate investing strategy, we must look for intelligent clues from the domestic and foreign markets and try to decode what the volatility and the rigorous imprisonment of the stock market in a 10 percent range tell us.
The first place to start, of course, is capital flows. Foreign institutional investors (the here-today-gone-tomorrow guys) hold the key to the Indian markets. And second-guessing their behaviour isn’t easy. For instance, in May, FIIs moved out large sums of money—a net Rs. 9,910 crore —leading to a sudden fall in the market. Their immediate provocation: The US economy was showing signs of sputtering to life. And the Indian rupee had strengthened, thus converting to more dollars and making it unattractive to bring in funds into the market. The Sensex was hovering at around 16.000, not much more than where it started five months ago.
Yet in the following month, investor attendance was overwhelming at the Morgan Stanley annual investor summit in India. There was one big fly in the ointment though. Even the largest global fund managers were worried stiff about the European crisis and its impact on the world markets. “They are convinced as ever with the India story, but the global overhang still remains,” says Desai.
Now, there’s some evidence to suggest FIIs could end up as net sellers over the next few months. Emerging market investment expert Mark Mobius, who is the chief strategist for global investment firm Templeton, says that Indian equity valuations are not cheap compared to the historical averages. If investors like him follow this logic to stay away from the markets or even dilute their portfolio, the market would go back to being flattish till the year-end. Remember that stock prices have already factored in the expected earnings of corporate India in 2010-11. It is a compelling opportunity for FIIs to cash out now and return once valuations weaken a bit.
- Shankar Sharma: The alchemist of Dalal Street
- Rakesh Jhunjhunwala: Nifty could reach 1,25,000 by 2030
- 'India Can Translate Optimism Into Real Growth': Chetan Ahya, Morgan Stanle...
- A Guide to Forbes India 20 Stocks Portfolio
- Wealth wizards: Follow the 'keep it simple' policy for investments